Five Reasons Why New Yorkers Shouldn’t Get a Puppy for Christmas

Although shelters and breeders are hoping their resident animals find a warm, loving home for the holidays, they also don't want these animals to be returned months later.

Every year, children wake up on Christmas morning to find a puppy with a big red bow underneath the tree. Unfortunately for too many of those sweet puppies, they find themselves brought to a shelter for various reasons beyond their control.

Reasons Not to Get a Dog for Christmas

As a dog owner of a gorgeous collie named Harvey, let me be first to say that dogs are a tremendous responsibility - no matter their breed or "chill" factor. Harvey is, by far, the easiest dog I've ever had.

He doesn't mind being groomed, will politely let me know he needs to go outside, isn't a picky eater, and has a high tolerance level for my feral need to smother him in kisses and sing made-up-songs about his heroic deeds the second I think he looks extra adorable. Which is all the time.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Handsome Harvey (@harveytheroughcollie)

I mean just look at him!  He is 100% good quality dog.

Regardless of how amazing he is, Harvey requires a lot of time and attention - and money. Oh, so much money. Vet bills and dog food aren't cheap.

When Harvey came into my life in 2018, I had been planning on getting a dog of my own for several years.

While I grew up with collies and missed having one around, I waited until I knew the time was right to open my heart and home to my favorite breed.

Read More: These Are New York State's Most Popular Dog Names of 2023

Harvey was, by all means, a very easy puppy and yet he still had his moments.

He rode in cars like a champ, remembered commands, and loved everyone he met. The last part got him in some trouble though, as he had recall issues that required professional intervention from a dog trainer.

Working with Chelsea of Canine Curiosity on Harvey's recall was worth every penny - and that was a lot of pennies. 

Harvey, like all dogs, also went through a destructive phase while teething. He was able to get his mouth on several things I really wish he hadn't - like my first edition cover of "Sabriel," or my favorite bra.

Thankfully, he grew out of that phase, but some dogs don't.

All that said, here's five reasons why dogs don't make good Christmas gifts.

1. Dogs Are Expensive

Dog food has skyrocketed in price in recent years.

Harvey's food went from $36 a bag to $100 because of inflation.  He goes through it within 6 weeks, so I have to budget buying a brand new bag of food every month-and-a-half. 

Food aside, trips to the vet are also up there in price.

Your dog will need to undergo annual exams and require shots to protect them from rabies, distemper and other terrible illnesses.

Dogs also require maintenance such as regular brushing and professional grooming. Long-haired and double-coated breeds should be groomed every 4 to 6 weeks while dogs with short or fine hair should head in every 8 to 12 weeks. 

Hey, those anal glands ain't gonna express themselves. Just saying.

Read More: Shelter Dogs Becoming the Preferred Pet in New York State

For Harvey, grooming appointments cost around $120 depending on how much work he needs.

Money will also be needed to purchase toys, leashes, bowls, brushes and monthly medicines that prevent heartworm and fleas. All that stacks up into a pretty pricey monthly bill.

While these are all regular expenses, dog owners are all too aware unexpected costs like furniture repair or emergency vet trips can drain the wallet.

2. Dogs Test Your Patience

While puppies are cute, they need your help to be successful. There will be days you will come home to find total carnage and a happy dog sitting in the middle of it.

To them, they just had a rip roarin' good time while, to you, they just destroyed your favorite shoes.

However, nothing destroys a perfectly good dog faster than improper punishment because they don't understand human-like consequences like spanking and yelling.

Canines need to be disciplined differently than a naughty child and they will thrive when you help them understand the things that are and are not acceptable.

Read More: Why Is It So Hard to Find Pet-Friendly Rentals in Central New York?

Harvey had a penchant for eating walls. You hear me? WALLS. His puppy teeth sawed through trim, corners and uneven surfaces... even though his favorite chew toys were literally right next to him.

Teaching him to stop was a blast, sarcasm intended - but he eventually stopped when I was ready to tear out the last of my hair.

Dogs need a lot of patience and they will test you in many surprising ways.

3. Dogs Need a Lot of Attention

If you're getting a dog just because you like the idea of having one in the house, or your kids have been begging you for a puppy because their best friend's cousin's neighbor got one - then you're likely to be among the many families who will be dumping that poor dog at a shelter by Easter.

Dogs aren't plants that can be left alone and watered whenever you remember. They need plenty of exercise, socialization, and lots of love... and training.

In short, they really need you.

Adding a dog to your home permanently changes your schedule. You will need to make time to walk the dog, feed it, brush it, clean up after it, play with it, and - most importantly - love it.

I have had to pause many gaming nights with friends or work assignments because Harvey gave me the sign he needed to "do his business." There were also moments where he began projectile vomiting everywhere.

Dogs don't magically turn out perfect, they need a lot of time and attention to get to that level and you must be willing to put in the work.

While the benefits are well worth it, you end up sacrificing a lot of time.

4. Dogs' Needs Change As They Get Older

A puppy doesn't stay a puppy forever and their routine will change the second you get used to it.

You will need to adapt with your pet because they rely on you.

Example: If your child is begging for a puppy, you need to make sure they're not thinking they'll be taking care of a puppy forever.

Puppies grow into dogs and they can get large. Unfortunately, that is one of the main reasons why people dump dogs at the pound - they grew out of the cute puppy stage and are now "too big."

Read More: Has This Mysterious Illness in Dogs Spread to New York?

Some dogs grow up to be extremely strong while others become very vocal. Others develop boundless energy and will require lots of physical activity to burn through it.

It's your job to research the breed of dog you want before buying it so you are prepared to handle their "quirks" as they grow - especially as they enter senior age.

So if you love your peace and quiet, a husky is definitely not for you.

Another issue at the shelter is that many senior dogs are surrendered because the owners don't want to take care of them anymore. Elderly dogs may require certain medicines to continue living comfortably, and some pet owners find it to be too much to handle.

While the dogs you own are around for a part of your life, you are in theirs for their entire life.

5. A Dog Is a Commitment, Not a Present

To sum it all up, a dog or puppy is not a present that you put under the tree and wash your hands of it. Dogs are a 10-year commitment, at least!

They aren't the latest iPhone or gaming console that becomes obsolete the second a newer model is released.

Dogs take a lot of time to train, housebreak, socialize, and become the dog you want them to be. You also will be thinking questions you never had before, like, "Who will watch my dog when I go on this week-long vacation?"

If your child is hellbent on getting a dog, you need to make sure they are ready for the responsibility. You need to trust that you won't be bringing that dog to the shelter in a few weeks because the apple lost its shine.

To Wrap This Up...

In all, dogs are not Christmas presents. They're a big responsibility that need you to be 100 percent committed.

I wouldn't be writing this long-winded, semi-proselytizing article if it wasn't coming from a place of caring.

Adding a dog to my family was the best choice I ever made and we're about to celebrate seven wonderful years together.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Handsome Harvey (@harveytheroughcollie)

I hope you get to experience that special kind of love and loyalty only a dog can give. But, I also hope you are in a place where your dog always feels loved, safe and wanted.

Thank you for coming to my Ted Talk. I'll show myself out.

Get our free mobile app