Scotty McCreery Safe – Casey Abrams Eliminated From ‘American Idol’
And then there were five.
Ryan Seacrest told us at the top of the show we would be disappointed with the outcome - and he wasn't wrong: In somewhat of a shocker, Casey Abrams was eliminated from 'American Idol.' And for Scotty McCreery fans, its was a nerve wracking night, since it came down to Scotty or Casey. Right on the heels of one of Scottys' best performances yet.