Ready to clear out the clutter and make a few bucks? A garage sale is a perfect way to lighten your load and pad your wallet. But if you’re not careful with your pricing, you could scare off bargain hunters or worse, give away the good stuff for pennies.

Why Garage Sales Still Work in Central New York

Sure, you could list everything on Facebook Marketplace or try your luck with a local Buy Nothing group, but nothing beats the old-school charm of a weekend tag sale. In neighborhoods from Whitesboro to Manlius, garage sales are still a great way to:

• Connect with your community

• Get rid of things in bulk

• Score a little cash while you’re at it

Plus, many local towns, including Utica, Fayetteville, and Clay have designated "community sale weekends," which means more foot traffic and better chances of selling.

Central NY Garage Sale Tips

Follow the 10% Rule

A good general rule? Price items around 10% of their original retail cost. Bought a lamp for $40 at Target? Try pricing it at $4. Exceptions: anything new, rare, or collectible. Those can go for 20–30%.

Read More: Can You Handle New York’s Massive Bounce House?

Focus on Volume

In CNY neighborhoods, the best garage sales are the ones with lots of stuff at great prices. If you’ve got high-end or vintage items, list those online (think eBay or Facebook Marketplace). But for everything else? Price to move.

Leave Tags On

Still have the tags on an item? Use that to your advantage and mark it a bit higher. Shoppers love “new with tags” deals, especially at garage sales.

Keep the Change

Cash is still king at most garage sales across Central New York. Make sure you’ve got plenty of $1s and quarters on hand.

Check Local Pricing

Before your sale weekend, hit up other garage sales in your area or swing by a thrift shop to get a feel for what prices are working locally.

Bundle Deals That Work

People love a good deal, and bundle pricing is a great way to clear out more items. Try signs like:

• “Fill a bag of clothes for $5”

• “Buy 3 books, get 1 free”

• “All DVDs: 4 for $2”

How to Handle Haggling Like a Local

It’s not a garage sale unless someone offers you $1 for a $10 item.

• Start high, but not too high. If you think something’s worth $5, list it at $7 so you can negotiate.

• Be friendly. Bargaining is part of the fun, especially in small towns.

• Stay flexible. If it’s the end of the day and something’s still sitting there? Let it go for less.

Read More: Utica’s Brand-New Children’s Museum Is Officially Open

Bonus: CNY Garage Sale Prep Checklist

• Check with your town for permit rules or community sale dates

• Gather folding tables, price tags, and change

• Advertise on Facebook groups like “Garage Sales Near Utica” or Nextdoor

• Post signs with bold arrows in nearby intersections

• Offer coffee or bottled water to bring people in!

Watch the Weather!

Garage sale success often depends on sunshine. Keep an eye on the forecast, especially during rainy springs or unpredictable fall weekends.