Best Pizza Places in Utica on Yelp

It's National Pizza Day. Whether you prefer deep dish, thin crust or upside down pizza, there are millions of ways to enjoy a pie in celebration. And with all the different pizzerias in Utica, there are plenty of places to order. But who serves the best slice of pizza? Here's the top 10 pizza places in Utica on Yelp.

1. O’scugnizzo Pizzeria

O'scugnizzo Pizzeria is not only the 2nd oldest pizzeria in America, opening in 1914. It's also home to the infamous upside down pizza.

614 Bleecker St
Utica, NY 13501
Phone number (315) 732-6149

REVIEWS
Fox E from Buffalo NY - "O'scugnizzo Pizzeria is the best pizza I've had in Utica. It's the most unusual Pizza I've had in NY State, and it's one of the more delicious pizzas you're ever likely to put in your mouth."

Sun B from Las Vegas - "I have lived in 4 states and this is still by far the BEST PIZZA EVER!"

2. Slice Pizzeria

Sliced opened in 2013 and has already gained a 5 star reputation for it's delicious gourmet pizzas and Purple Cow wings.

2007 Genesee St
Utica, NY 13501
Phone number (315) 507-3197

REVIEWS
D.V from Las Vegas "I was home visiting and tried Slice out I have to say they nailed it. The food is excellent, great service, great prices. The house pizza was great, you have try the Purple Cow Wings. And the NY Pizza is good also."

3. Parkway Pizza

Parkway Pizza is family owned and operated.

1250 Culver Ave
Utica, NY 13501
Phone number (315) 733-8585

REVIEWS
Chad from Columbia South Carolina "I really can not say enough positive things about parkway. It is easily the best pizzeria in central New York."

4. Pizza Classic

Pizza Classic has been serving Utica for 25 years.

180 Genesee St
Utica, NY 13502
Phone number (315) 735-3000

REVIEWS
Stacey K "I'm from Long Island originally and grew up with hand-tossed pizza with a crust that is thinner, crisp on the bottom but with a little bit of doughy feel. Quality sauce makes the pizza and this place has both."

5. Franco’s Pizza & Deli

Franco's Pizza & Deli has been serving customers since 1972.

411 Trenton Ave
Utica, NY 13502
Phone number (315) 724-6232

REVIEWS
Anne From Ashburn Virgina "Every time I visit Utica I must go to Franco's at least once. The pizza is amazing. The crust is always cooked well and the sauce is well spiced."

6. Lukins Brick Oven Pizza

Lukins is more than home to authentic brick oven pizza. You can enjoy live music while eating your pizza on Varick street.

640 Varrick St
Utica, NY 13502
Phone number (315) 735-8546

REVIEWS
Kristin Fountain Valley, CA "Margherita pizza with a basalmic glaze...oh boy...try it, love it."

7. Jonnys Pizza

Jonnys Pizza hasn't even been open a year but is quickly becoming a popular place for the best pizza in town.

100 Genesee St
Utica, NY 13502
Phone number (315) 507-4577

REVIEWS
Anne P. from Buffalo Grove, Illinois "Found this gem on the way home from a long road trip and it felt so good to finally have a piece of delicious, New York style pizza."

8. Rosario’s Pizzeria East Utica

It’s affordable, it’s fresh, it’s warm. Rosario's is a place where friends come together to enjoy a delicious meal.

1803 Welsh Bush Rd
Utica, NY 13501
Phone number (315) 724-6016

REVIEWS
Edward A. from ASTORIA, NY "Best Pizza in Utica."

9. Charlie’s Pizza

Charlie's Pizza prides itself on serving food that originated from family recipes.

350 Leland Ave
Utica, NY 13502
Phone number (315) 738-8946

REVIEWS
Will H from Binghamton New York "This pizza is outstanding! Best in town and that is saying a lot. This hand tossed pizza is made by staff that have been there for years perfecting their craft. This is not a novice pizza shop. This is a serious pizza lover establishment. You will not find a better pizza."

Who do you think has the best pizza in Utica?

MORE: Jelly Bun Commercial Audition